Best Serums for Under-Eye Puffiness: My Tested Reviews & Results

Struggling with tired, puffy eyes? Over the years, I’ve tested countless under-eye serums. Here’s what worked—and what didn’t (with pictures).

by: Linda Robison / Facial Fitness Specialist @ ABZ

Under-eye puffiness, whether it's caused by aging, allergies, or lifestyle factors, can make you look tired and older than you feel. And when puffiness or fine lines get in the way, even applying eyeliner makeup can be tricky.

That’s why I put together these 10 eyeliner makeup tips for aging eyes, so you can get a smooth, flattering look that enhances your eyes at any age.

Understanding what’s triggering your puffiness and how to reduce it can make a big difference. My How to Reduce Puffy Eyes guide covers the most effective remedies.

If you need a fast fix, I’ve tested powerful products that instantly tighten skin and reduce puffiness. Some worked better than others—I'll break it all down for you.

A woman massaging under-eye serum into her skin.

Why I needed a puffy eye solution

I've had lower eyelid puffiness and wrinkles since my early 20s! And, now that I'm older, my under-eye skin can look a bit wrinkly and crêpey!

Under eye puffiness before and after using over the counter under eye serums that instantly tighten and lift.My before and after results using serums under-eye puffiness. These photos have NOT been altered. The EES serum helps blur away undereye lines.

I knew I had to find a solution!

Most of the under-eye serums I've tried worked, but they all had side effects or issues I didn’t like. So I kept trying & testing new products.

In this article, I’ll share what I found to help you figure out which ones might work for you.

My tested picks

This article reviews my experiences with the following products:

  1. Plexaderm Rapid Reduction
  2. Preparation-H Hemorrhoid cream
  3. Peter Thomas Roth FirmX
  4. Instantly Ageless
  5. Insta-Tox
  6. Easy Eye Solution
  7. Dr. Brandt No More Baggage

Reviews & My results

Note: These reviews are just my opinion. Try different products to see what works best for you.

After testing these serums, here's my experience with each one, what worked, what didn’t, and what to consider based on your skin type.

1. Plexaderm Rapid Reduction Eye Serum

Plexaderm Serum: Improved formula, mixed results

  • New serum formula is hydrating and smoother than the original cream.
  • Works best on bare skin without makeup.
  • Alternatives like Easy Eye Solutions may suit sensitive skin better.

When I first tried Plexaderm for under-eye swelling, it was a cream-based formula. However, the company has since reformulated it into a liquid serum, which might perform better. I haven’t tried the newer version yet.

My experience with their original cream was similar to Ageless—it felt dry, difficult to work with, and often needed water to thin it out.

While I can't comment on the effectiveness of the new serum, I personally prefer light serum-based products for addressing under-eye puffiness.

What's better than Plexaderm for under-eye puffiness?

Looking for something better than Plexaderm? It really depends on what your skin needs.

If you're dealing with puffiness and fine lines, but hate the dry or flaky finish some formulas leave behind, here are two alternatives I liked better:

  • Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx Eye Gel – Tightens the under-eye area and layers better under makeup.
  • Easy Eye Solutions Instant Eye Tuck – Gentler on sensitive skin, smooth application, and makeup-friendly.

Unlike Plexaderm’s thicker texture, these are lightweight, easier to apply, and less likely to flake. If Plexaderm has ever cracked on you—or made applying concealer a pain—you’ll probably prefer one of these.

Need help deciding which is better for your situation? See my full breakdown of Plexaderm vs Competitors.

2. Preparation-H Hemorrhoid Cream

Photo of preparation H under eye puffiness.

Preparation-H hemorrhoid cream: Not for under-eye puffiness

  • Not designed for under-eye use.
  • Can cause irritation or swelling due to heavy, greasy formula.
  • Widely considered ineffective for puffiness.

I know—Preparation-H for puffy eyes sounds like one of those weird beauty hacks that’s too out there to ignore. And since some people (even a few celebs) have claimed it helps, I had to try it for myself.

Spoiler: It wasn’t worth the hype.

This cream isn’t made for the delicate skin under the eyes, and it didn’t help reduce my puffiness or refresh my look. If anything, the thick, greasy formula made things feel heavier, and my eyes looked a little more swollen afterward. 

Note: Some dermatologists and skincare specialists warn that Preparation-H may irritate delicate under-eye area. Read more here: Can Preparation-H can damage under-eye skin. 😮 


newsletter sign up

3. Instantly Ageless

Remedy for puffy under eyes. Sample of Instantly Ageless.

Instantly Ageless: Effective but flaky

  • Effectively reduces puffiness initially.
  • Flaky residue appears after a few hours.
  • Difficult to apply smoothly; doesn’t work well over makeup.

Many YouTube videos show positive results, but I struggled with the application—it was chunky and required water to smooth, possibly due to an old product.

Initially, it reduced puffiness and tightened my skin, but after a few hours, it flaked and peeled like eczema. Applying it over creams or makeup didn’t help and only worsened the dryness.

4. Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx Eye Gel

Quick fix for puffy eyes

Peter Thomas Roth: Quick results, powdery residue

  • Reduces puffiness effectively within minutes.
  • Can leave a tight, dry, or powdery residue if overapplied.
  • Works better when mixed with a drop of water for smoother application.
  • Ideal for quick fixes, especially for events.
Thomas Roth puffy eye serum compared to Easy Eye Solutions.Under-eye puffiness is less, but I don't like the white film it left. Using less serum can help reduce with the film.

This eye firming gel gets results—it visibly reduces under-eye puffiness. However, it can feel a bit too tight and slightly drying, sometimes leaving a powdery residue.

Using less product or mixing in a tiny drop of water made a big difference for me. If you're open to tweaking the application, it could be a great option for under-eye puffiness.

Wondering which if Peter Thomas Roth lasts as long as Plexaderm? Check out this comparison.

5. INSTA-TOX - Serious Skincare

eye serum for puffy eyes

INSTA-TOX: Best for mild puffiness

  • Light formula, though very wet and prone to sputtering without proper shaking.
  • Works decently for mild under-eye puffiness, but not potent enough for severe bags or dark circles.
  • Dries to a powdery residue, which may be noticeable.
  • Less effective compared to Peter Thomas Roth for long-lasting results.

This eye serum is very liquid and can sputter if you don’t shake the tube first, likely due to ingredient separation.

While it’s okay, it’s not as effective as Peter Thomas Roth for severe under-eye bags or dark circles. It also sets to a powdery film, which I’m not a fan of.

If I have to deal with a white residue, I’d rather use Peter Thomas Roth.

6. Easy Eye Solutions Instant Eye Tuck

Looking for best products for puffy eyes.

Easy Eye Solutions: My top pick for under-eye bags

  • Soft, gentle formula that reduces puffiness without drying or cracking.
  • Works seamlessly under makeup for a smooth finish.
  • Camouflages criss-cross and fine lines and crepe-like texture effectively.
  • Ideal for sensitive or mature skin types.

This anti-aging eye treatment serum worked best for me. It’s soft, not too drying and does not crack or accentuate my under-eye lines when I smile. 

It also helps camouflage those tiny wrinkles and crepe-like lines

See how Easy Eye Solution visibly reduces extreme puffiness in this video—perfect for tackling even the most stubborn under-eye bags.





7. Dr. Brandt No More Baggage

Dr. Brandt No More Baggage Serum tube for reducing puffy eyes, dark circles, and under-eye bags—innovative eye care solution for tired eyes.

Dr. Brandt: Good for light puffiness

  • Soft gel formula that doesn’t require shaking.
  • Works well for mild puffiness and brightening the under-eye area.
  • Requires practice to find the right amount for smooth application.
  • Dries clear on the skin, with no visible residue.

    • This product is similar to Insta-Tox but has a softer gel consistency and doesn’t require shaking to mix.

    It took a few tries to get the application right. It initially felt a bit pasty, but warming it between my fingertips before applying under my eyes helped.

    You might need to experiment with the amount. Though it looks tan/flesh-colored, it dries clear on my skin.

    Top 3 picks: For Under-Eye Solutions

    These are my favorite products to tackle under-eye puffiness.

    1. Easy Eye Solutions:

    This is my top choice for smoothing and tightening the under-eye area. It delivers long-lasting results and works beautifully under makeup.

    2. Peter Thomas Roth Instant FirmX Eye Gel:

    A fantastic option for quick fixes, this gel visibly reduces puffiness and fine lines within minutes. Perfect for special events or when you're short on time.

    3. Dr. Brandt No More Baggage:

    This lightweight gel not only depuffs but also helps brighten the under-eye area, making you look refreshed and awake.

    Give these a try and find the one that fits your needs best! If you've tried any of these, I'd love to hear your results!

    How to effectively use an Under Eye Puffiness Serum

    Best Way to Get a Flawless Finish

    To reap the benefits of under-eye serums, you need to know how to apply them correctly. You don't need to be a makeup artist to get it right. You don't need to use a setting spray, setting powder, or cream concealers.

    And you don't need a beauty blender or makeup brush to smooth it on...Just your ring finger. Here is my advice:

    Small drop of under eye puffy serum.In this photo, I'm using the Easy Eye Solution Serum.
    1. Apply a non-oily hydrating eye cream under the eyes.
    2. Apply a tiny drop, half the size of a pea—don’t overdo it!
    3. Gently smooth it from the inner corners under the lash line outward across the undereye area.

    A little goes a long way, adjust the amount next time until you find what works. I usually apply this serum after finishing my makeup, just before heading out the door.



    Best eye serum for puffy eyes: Summary

    Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links

    Here is a quick summary of the review of anti-aging eye products I've tried: EES, Peter Thomas Roth, Plexaderm, Instantly Ageless, Insta-TOX, Dr. Brandt No More Baggage.

    • Easy Eye Solutions (EES)  - is by far the most effective, less drying and easy to apply. Just swipe it under each eye, let dry, and you're ready to go!

    EES - 50% OFF & FREE Shipping

    EES - On Amazon  

    • Peter Thomas Roth - worked well to reduce puffiness, But it might be too drying for sensitive or mature skin.

    Peter Thomas Roth FirmX on Amazon

    • Plexaderm Rapid Reduction - I was not too crazy about the old version. I don't know what the serum feels like. But, if you're interested in trying, you can purchase it on Amazon.

    Plexaderm Rapid Reduction Eye Serum on Amazon

    • Instantly Ageless - for me this was the hardest to work with and didn't last as long as the others.

    Instantly Ageless on Amazon

    • Insta-TOX Serious Skincare - Meh. It was ok, I didn't like how it dried. And it's a little hard to work with because it's so wet.

    Serious Skincare Insta-TOX on Amazon

    • Dr. Brandt No More Baggage - Not bad, but not my favorite. It’s not too drying, but it doesn’t provide much firming either. Would probably work well for mild puffiness. 

    Dr. Brandt No More Baggage



    FAQs

    Question: Is Plexaderm the same as hemorrhoid cream?

    Answer: No, Plexaderm is not the same as a hemorrhoid cream. Plexaderm is for the under-eye area, and hemorrhoid creams are used to reduce swollen hemorrhoids in the lower region of the body. 

    Question: Is there a permanent way to hide eye bags after 50?

    Answer:  For those looking for more lasting results, Fillers or Botox might be some options to consider. Explore Botox for eye bags and dermal fillers for under eye puffiness, for a smoother, more refreshed under-eye area.

    Question: Insta-Tox vs Plexiderm vs Peter Roth? Which did you like the best?

    Answer: No, question, I like Peter Thomas Roth FirmX. It's easy to use and it works without crusting or leaving a whitish film. Only down side? It's a bit drying.

    Question: What is the main ingredient in plexaderm?

    Answer: Plexaderm's active ingredient, sodium silicate, temporarily tightens the skin by forming a thin film on the surface, creating a smoother appearance.

    Question: Peter Thomas Roth vs Plexaderm? Which is better?

    Answer: Personally, I prefer Peter Thomas Roth FirmX vs Plexaderm. It has a thinner gel like consistency and is easy to apply and work with.

    Question: What's an alternative to Plexaderm?

    Answer:  Easy Eye Solution (EES) Instant Eye Tuck is my first alternative to Plexaderm. And Peter Thomas Roth FirmX is my second choice.

    Both are easy to work with and both are a light gel that goes on smoothly. The difference is the EES is lighter and less drying, but both work very well, especially for sensitive, mature under eye skin.

    Question: Does Benadryl help puffy eyes from crying?

    Answer: Benadryl might help better if your issue is caused by an allergic response or seasonal allergies. But, it might take a few days to see results. You're better off using a cold compress like tea bags to reduce eye swelling from crying.

    Question: Does Garnier eye cream fix eye bags?

    Answer: I've tried and wrote about my experience using Garnier eye cream. It didn't remove or reduce the appearance of puffiness, but it didn't make it worse. However, I did think it was a bit pricey for a drugstore brand eye product.

    Question: Why do I suddenly have wrinkles under my eyes?

    Answer: A few reasons why those little lines might have decided to make an appearance include:

    Age: As you age, your skin loses elasticity and collagen, leading to wrinkles.
    Dehydration: Not drinking enough water leaves your skin dry and more prone to fine lines.
    Sleep Habits: Lack of quality sleep often results in extra lines, especially under the eyes.
    Sun Exposure: UV rays accelerate collagen and elastin breakdown, causing premature wrinkles. But consistent sunscreen use can help reverse some skin aging.
    Smoking: Smoking reduces blood flow and damages collagen, contributing to lines.
    Squinting: Regular squinting from sunlight or poor vision can create lines around your eyes.
    Genetics: If your parents developed under-eye wrinkles early, you might too.

    Visit: 5 Eye wrinkle remedies that work for some simple, at-home solutions to fine lines and eye wrinkles.

    Question: Is Vaseline good for eye bags?

    Answer: No! There is no indication that Vaseline contains anything to help reduce under eye swelling. Personally, I would never use Vaseline under the eye area. Anything greasy like that would cause my eyes to swell up! 

    Question: Can you use Preparation H on your face for wrinkles

    Answer: No, Preparation-H will not have any effect for smoothing out wrinkles on your face or anywhere else.

    Question: Does Plexaderm work on turkey neck wrinkles?

    Answer: No, Plexaderm is designed to temporarily smooth the appearance of lines, and eye bags. Wrinkles on the neck are caused by loose, sagging skin, reduced elasticity, and a lack of muscle tone. If you're looking for natural solutions to tighten a turkey neck, check out this post. You'll also find my before and after neck pictures.

    Question: What's the difference between Insta-tox vs Plexaderm?

    Answer: Insta-tox has a consistency similar to Peter Thomas Roth FirmX. It's a thick, white gel. It works similar but the FirmX,  but stronger and a bit more drying.

    Question: Can you apply makeup over Plexaderm?

    Answer: I never had success in applying makeup or concealer over Plexaderm. But it could because I use an oily-based foundation. However, if you want to try to apply makeup over Plexaderm or any puffy under eye serum, here are some tips:

    1. After applying Plexaderm, let it dry completely before applying makeup.
    2. Use a light touch as heavy applications can disrupt the product.
    3. Opt for lightweight, breathable, water-based or silicone-based makeup.
    4. If you apply foundation, lightly dust with a translucent setting powder.

    Question: Can you wear makeup over Plexaderm?

    Answer: Yes, you can wear makeup over Plexaderm, but it’s best to use it sparingly and follow these tips for the best results:

    1. Wait for Plexaderm to Set: Allow the product to fully dry and set (about 10 minutes) before applying makeup.
    2. Use Oil-Free Products: Opt for lightweight, oil-free makeup to avoid breaking down the Plexaderm.
    3. Pat, Don’t Rub: Gently pat on makeup rather than rubbing to maintain the tightened effect.

    Powder-based makeup often works better than heavy liquid foundations to avoid disrupting the product's hold.

    Question: What's the best drugstore eye cream for puffiness?

    Answer: Two popular drugstore brands that support under-eye skin health are CeraVe Eye Repair Cream and RoC Retinol Correxion Eye Cream. These aren't quick-fix serums but work best for long-term eye skin health.

    CeraVe hydrates and soothes mild puffiness with hyaluronic acid and ceramides, helping restore the skin barrier. Results vary depending on puffiness or wrinkles.

    RoC targets fine lines, puffiness, and dark circles with retinol, which boosts collagen and smooths skin. Many users see results in a few weeks, but don’t forget sunscreen when using retinol.

    Question: What is Better Than Plexaderm?

    Answer:  Many users find that Peter Thomas Roth Instant FIRMx is better than Plexaderm because it provides a smoother, longer-lasting finish without flaking. Unlike Plexaderm, which may leave a visible residue, Instant FIRMx blends more naturally into the skin.

    Question: Peter Thomas Roth Instant FirmX Eye vs. Plexaderm – Which Lasts Longer?

    Answer: Peter Thomas Roth Instant FirmX Eye typically lasts longer. Many find that its effects can last up to 8 hours, while Plexaderm may start to wear off sooner, especially with facial movement. However, proper application is key—using too much of either product can lead to residue or flaking, which may shorten the wear time.

    You might like these

    About the Author:
    Linda Robison is a Facial Fitness Specialist and the founder of Anti-Aging Beauty Zone. She shares expert insights on skincare, facial rejuvenation, and beauty treatments—blending traditional wisdom, personal experience, and science-backed research for both at-home and in-office solutions.

    Before you go ....

    Please tap on the💙in the bottom right corner if you found this page helpful. Also, Let’s CONNECT! Click the buttons below to follow me on social media.

    Thanks so much!