How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Wrinkled Eyelids (No Smudging or Tugging!)

by: Linda Robison / Facial Fitness Specialist @ ABZ

Finding the right eyeliner for wrinkled eyelids can be frustrating. Some formulas smudge, settle into fine lines, or tug at delicate skin, making application tricky. But the good news? The right eyeliner can enhance your eyes without creasing or fading.

In this guide, you’ll learn:

• Why some eyeliners don’t work for aging skin
• How to choose a smudge-proof, easy-glide formula
• The best eyeliner types & colors for mature eyes
• How to prevent eyeliner from smudging or fading throughout the day

Why some eyeliners don't work on wrinkled eyelids?

Quick Answer: Many eyeliners fail on mature eyelids because they’re either too creamy (settling into lines), too dry (tugging the skin), overly pigmented (creating harsh lines), or not long-lasting (smudging easily).

Not all eyeliners are created equal—some just don’t work well on mature skin. Many women over 50 tell me they’ve stopped wearing eyeliner altogether because it’s too tricky to apply or doesn't look right.

That's a shame because I truly believe the right eyeliner can brighten older eyes, define your face, and even add a hint of sexy!

Common problems include:

• Too Creamy: Smudges and settles into fine lines.
• Too Dry: Tugs on delicate skin and skips when applied.
• Too Pigmented: Harsh lines can make eyes look smaller or tired.
• Not Long-Wearing: Fades or transfers onto eyelids throughout the day.

I've found the key is choosing an eyeliner that glides smoothly without smudging or fading. I'll show you exactly what to look for below.

What to look for in an eyeliner?

When shopping for eyeliner, focus on the formula, finish, and staying power to avoid smudging and creasing.

1. Best formula for wrinkled eyelids

• Gel Pencils – Soft, blendable, and long-wearing.
• Waxy Pencils – Smooth application and less likely to smudge.
• Cream-Based Gel Liners – Glides easily and stays put.

Avoid: Liquid eyeliners that dry too fast, leading to cracking.

2. Waterproof vs. Smudge-proof

• Waterproof eyeliners - Great for all-day wear but can be drying.
• Smudge-proof eyeliners - Easier to remove but still long-wearing.

Best Choice? If you have dry or sensitive skin, go for smudge-proof over waterproof to prevent flaking and irritation. I also find smudge-proof liners easier to work with and remove.

3. Matte vs. Satin vs. Shimmer

• Matte Finish: Best choice for mature skin; doesn't emphasize wrinkles.
• Satin or Soft-Shimmer Finish: Gives a subtle glow without highlighting lines.

Avoid Metallic or Glittery Finishes: Can emphasize texture and fine lines.

What color is best aging eyes?

Ok, the general rule of thumb for color selection is:

• Fair skin: Look for softer shades like taupe and light browns.
• Darker skin: Embrace vibrant tones like plum and teal.
• Brown or hazel eyes: Try purples, greens, or golds to enhance your natural eye color.

That's just a general guideline, though—not a strict rule. I'm in my 60s with fair skin and still wear black eyeliner, but I choose a softer formula that doesn't look harsh.

(I personally love Maybelline's black eyeliner—it has just the right balance of pigment.)

The key is to experiment because shades and formulas make a huge difference. Too intense a color can highlight wrinkles, while the right one enhances your eyes beautifully.

Remember, not all blacks (or any colors) are created equal. Brands vary in depth and richness, and pencils, gels, or crayons all apply differently. Play around and find what makes you look and feel great!

How to prevent smudging or fading?

The best ways to prevent eyeliner from smudging or fading include prepping your lids properly, using setting powder, and setting eyeliner with eyeshadow.

• Start with a smooth base - Apply a light layer of primer or concealer.
• Use a setting powder - Lightly dust translucent powder over your liner.
• Tightline for a natural look - Apply eyeliner to the upper waterline.
• Set with eyeshadow - A similar-toned powder will keep it locked in.

Want step-by-step details with helpful pictures? See 10 Smart Tricks Eyeliner Makeup Tricks You Need to Try!

Does dark eyeliner make you look older? My experience

Many makeup artists suggest light brown or taupe eyeliner for mature skin, but I’ve found these shades make my eyelids look wrinkled and tired.

Note: Don’t just listen to what others say—everyone is different! What works for one person might not work for you.

Instead, I prefer a dark purple cream gel liner or a classic black pencil, but only if it's a waxy, lightly pigmented formula that I can build up gradually. The trick is to avoid heavily pigmented or harsh formulas that can make eyes look smaller.

Pro Tip: If black eyeliner feels too harsh, try brown, navy, or plum for a softer, more flattering definition.

Want product suggestions? See my Best Eyeliners for Aging Eyes.

Final Takeaway: 

Choosing eyeliner for wrinkled eyelids isn't about strict rules—it's about what works best for you. In general:

• Gel Eyeliner: Smooth and ideal for crinkly eyelids; won't settle into wrinkles.
• Waxy Pencil Eyeliner: Great for soft definition without harsh lines.
• Liquid Gel Eyeliner: Precise, but requires a steady hand.

Avoid stiff, dry formulas that tug on delicate skin and metallic or glittery finishes that emphasize fine lines.

Bottom Line: Experiment until you find what makes you look and feel confident!

Before you go ....

Please tap on the💙in the bottom right corner if you found this page helpful. Also, Let’s CONNECT! Click the buttons below to follow me on social media.

Thanks so much!

FREE! Download this Cheek Shaper Video to help lift and firm your cheeks, giving you a more youthful, refreshed look! 💖