The Best Eyeliners for Aging Eyes

by: Linda Robison / Facial Fitness Specialist @ ABZ

Best Eyeliners for Aging Eyes: Keep Laughing and Lining

Makeup is our trusty sidekick, especially as we age. And eyeliner? Well, I consider it my magic wand, instantly giving life and definition to my eyes. I just can't ever go without eyeliner! Whether you're aiming for a classic vibe or a bold statement, eyeliner is an essential tool in our beauty arsenal.

With so many options—pencils, gels, liquids, and more—it can be tricky to pick the right one. When choosing an eyeliner, think about ease of application, staying power, and whether it's gentle on your eyes. 

Remember, the skin around our eyes gets more delicate with age and fine lines can start to show up. Finding an eyeliner that’s gentle and easy to apply is an important feature!

Below we've gathered the best eyeliners for aging eyes to keep your eyes looking fabulous at any age! Once you’ve found the perfect one, be sure to check out these 10 smart tricks for applying eyeliner on aging eyes to master your look.

Best eyeliners for aging eyes: Our top picks

We've gathered our top picks for eyeliners that make aging eyes pop. Trust us, we’ve tried it all! So, let’s dive into our best finds and have a little fun along the way.

iMethod Eyeliner Stamp

This is a game-changer for anyone who's ever struggled with getting the perfect winged eyeliner.

Pros

  • Quick and easy to use
  • Stays on all day
  • Works on all eye shapes

Cons

  • Liquid liner may feel tacky
  • Might not be fully waterproof
  • Some find the liner quality lacking

We love how the iMethod Eyeliner Stamp makes applying eyeliner a breeze. The stamp is well-inked and helps create perfect wings every time. The dual-ended design, with a stamp on one end and a fine liner on the other, means we can fill in precisely and get symmetrical wings effortlessly.

One downside is that the liquid liner can feel a bit tacky when applied. It’s also a good idea to use an eye shadow primer if you have oily skin since this helps the liner stay put even longer. Despite these minor issues, the convenience of the stamp makes it worth a try.

In our experience, the iMethod Eyeliner Stamp’s waterproof claims might be slightly exaggerated as it can smudge if our eyes water. But the ease of application and the confidence boost from having symmetrical wings keep us coming back. Give it a go if you're looking to simplify your eyeliner routine!

HOSAILY Eyeliner Stencils

A nifty tool to simplify your eyeliner routine, though it has its quirks.

Pros

  • Reusable and high quality
  • Beginner-friendly design
  • Multi-functional

Cons

  • Measurements hard to read
  • Not ideal for all eye shapes
  • Somewhat tricky to master

Let's talk about these HOSAILY Eyeliner Stencils. They've made our makeup game less stressful with these simple little tools. From drawing cat eyes to keeping our lipstick neat, we found uses beyond just eyeliner. It’s compact and fits easily into any makeup bag, making it great for travel. And hey, it’s reusable so we don't feel wasteful.

On the downside, the measurements on the silicone ruler are a bit too small to be practical. We also noticed it doesn't perfectly fit every eye shape, so it may not be a universal solution. It did take us a few tries to get the hang of it, but practice makes perfect, right?

Overall, these stencils are a great addition to our makeup toolkit. They’re particularly useful for those of us still perfecting our makeup skills. While it's not a miracle maker, it’s a helpful aid we'll keep around for our beauty routines.

Revant Gel Eyeliner for Mature Women

If staying power is what you're after, this eyeliner won't disappoint.

Pros

Cons

  • May need frequent sharpening
  • Longevity might vary for different users
  • Pencil tip can break easily

Using the Revant Gel Eyeliner felt like a breeze. Its rounded tip made it simple to draw smooth and precise lines, which is great for aging eyes. We liked how it stayed put throughout the day without smudging, even during our morning workout.

We noticed it sometimes needs sharpening more often than other pencils, but that's a small trade-off for its performance. Plus, the color payoff was rich and natural-looking, enhancing our eyes without looking overdone.

Despite a few minor hiccups like the occasional breakage of the pencil tip, it's a solid pick for anyone wanting their eyeliner to stay in place all day. If you’re always on the go and need reliable makeup, check out Revant Gel Eyeliner for Mature Women.

e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen

This is a fabulous eyeliner if you need something waterproof and easy to use.

Pros

  • Long-lasting wear
  • Quick-drying formula
  • Vegan & cruelty-free

Cons

  • Can feel a bit dry
  • Tip may wear out with time
  • Not ideal for extremely thin lines

We absolutely love the e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen. This handy little pen really delivers when it comes to getting that bold, dramatic look. The felt tip gives us so much control, whether we're going for a subtle line or a full-on cat-eye. Plus, it’s waterproof, so it’s not budging through any of our emotional movie marathons.

One of the things that really stands out is how long it lasts. We’ve worn it through humid days, sweated it out at the gym, and even gone swimming with it, and it still stays put. Let’s talk about the quick-dry formula—no one wants to deal with smudges right after application, and this product has that covered.

A minor drawback is that it can feel a bit dry and the tip might get worn out over time, especially if we’re using it daily. Also, if you’re aiming for super-thin lines, you might find it a bit challenging to achieve with this pen. But for the price and all the pros, it's a steal.

If you are looking for an effective and lovely eyeliner that’s budget-friendly and hassle-free, we’d totally recommend giving the e.l.f. H2O Proof Eyeliner Pen a try.

EpiLynx Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner

Perfect for those who want a vibrant, long-lasting eyeliner that’s also kind to sensitive skin.

Pros

Cons

  • Formula is quite wet
  • May dry out if not used regularly
  • Shiny finish might not appeal to everyone

We tried out the EpiLynx Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner and, wow, it’s seriously something! This purple hue is bright and perfect for adding a pop of color to our daily makeup routine. Applying it is a breeze thanks to the precision tip—it glides on smoothly, even if we're in a hurry.

On the other hand, we noticed the formula is pretty wet. It's easy to apply, but make sure you give it a few moments to dry. Also, if you don't use it frequently, it might dry out, so that's something to keep in mind.

What we absolutely love is how gentle it is. It’s free from gluten and allergens, making it suitable for sensitive skins. Plus, it's vegan and cruelty-free, which is always a win in our book. If you're in the market for a new eyeliner, EpiLynx's Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner is definitely worth a try!

Buying guide

So, we're diving into the world of eyeliners, specifically for our fabulous aging eyes. It's like a treasure hunt, except with way fewer pirates. Let's break down what we should look for when picking the perfect eyeliner.

Easy to apply

We want eyeliners that glide on smoothly. Think of it as spreading butter on warm toast. Look for ones that are creamy or gel-based. They’re easier to control and less likely to tug at our delicate skin.

Smudge-proof

Nobody wants to look like a raccoon by noon. Let's find eyeliners with serious staying power. Words like "waterproof" and "smudge-proof" should catch our attention.

Gentle formulas

Our eyes can be sensitive, like our feelings after watching a sad movie. Let's opt for gentle, hypoallergenic formulas. Look for eyeliners without harsh chemicals, so we won't feel like our eyes are on fire.

Pencil vs. Liquid vs. Gel

Different types for different vibes: Type Pros Cons Pencil Easy to use, natural look Needs frequent sharpening Liquid Precision, bold look Can be tricky to apply Gel Smooth application, blend Requires a brush

  • Pencil: Good for a soft, natural look. Needs sharpening.
  • Liquid: Sharp, precise lines but requires a steady hand.
  • Gel: Great blend of both. Needs a brush, though.

Color choices

Sticking with black or brown can be a safe bet. They're like the little black dress of the eyeliner world. For a softer look, consider dark gray or navy blue. Let's not go too wild with neon colors.

Pro-tip: Check reviews

Before we commit, let's do a little detective work. Checking reviews can save us from eyeliner disasters. Fellow makeup lovers often leave helpful tips and opinions.

And that’s our quick guide! Now, let’s go find that perfect eyeliner to rock our look!

FAQ:

Frequently Asked Questions

We've got the lowdown on all your burning eyeliner questions for those of us gracefully embracing our golden years.

What's the secret to applying eyeliner for the over 50 fabulous crowd?

It’s all about using a light hand and soft strokes. We want definition, not drama. Gel eyeliners are great for a smooth line. Remember, blending is our best friend!

How can you prevent eyeliner from settling into the fine masterpiece lines we've earned with age?

A good primer is key. It preps the lids and helps the eyeliner stay put. Avoid overly creamy formulas, as they tend to migrate into those fine lines.

Is there a holy grail eyeliner that won't play hide and seek in eye wrinkles?

Look for waterproof or long-wearing eyeliners. They are less likely to smudge. Brands like Stila’s Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner are fan favorites.

What eyeliner styles will help our eyes pop like stars in the sky, even with a little hooded eyelid action?

Tightlining is our go-to. Apply eyeliner to the upper waterline for a fuller lash look without taking up lid space. Also, a soft wing can lift the eye without being too harsh.

Can we still rock a cat eye after 60, or is it time to let that kitten nap?

Absolutely! A subtle cat eye can add a playful lift to our eyes. Just keep the line thin and slightly extend upwards. It’s all about that little flick!

Any tips for choosing eyeliner colors that make mature eyes sparkle like a sassy new romance?

Neutral shades like brown, gray, and navy are flattering and less harsh than black. For a fun twist, try plum or olive green. They can make our eye color pop without being too bold.

 



Before you go ....

Please tap on the💙in the bottom right corner if you found this page helpful.

Thanks so much!